Whom do I trust? I've undergone multiple ultrasounds and have gotten different results.

The ultrasound from 1 vascular surgeon says my left leg is fine and there is no sign of reflux. My right leg has reflux of 3.25 second behind my knee (GSV). The laser/radiofrequency procedure is NOT going to help my heaviness and aches of my legs as I do not have swelling nor varicose veins. The ultrasound from 2 other vein specialists show I have reflux in both legs (superficial veins and very mild on my deep vein as well). They recommend treatment. Whom do I trust?

Answers from doctors (5)


More About Doctor David Green, MD

Published on Nov 03, 2021

It is important to understand that symptoms (heaviness, aches) do not necessarily correlate with signs of venous insufficiency (varicose veins, reflux on ultrasound examination). Many people have varicose veins and reflux without any symptoms and others complain of symptoms with no recognizable varicose veins or any reflux of their deep or superficial venous systems.

Even if there are varicose veins or demonstrable reflux of the Saphenous Veins, there is no assurance that removal of these refluxing veins will have any effect on symptoms.

Duplex ultrasound examinations are usually administered by ultrasound vascular technicians. The technicians' skills and expertise can vary as do their results. You should obtain detailed copies of all your ultrasound reports and compare them. If there is a wide variation in findings you need to discover which findings are accurate and which are not. Very often, people undergo Endovenous Ablation and Sclerotherapy treatments when they were completely unnecessary.

Answered by David Green, MD (View Profile)

It is important to understand that symptoms (heaviness, aches) do not necessarily correlate with signs of venous insufficiency (varicose veins, reflux on ultrasound examination). Many people have varicose veins and reflux without any symptoms and others complain of symptoms with no recognizable varicose veins or any reflux of their deep or superficial venous systems.

Even if there are varicose veins or demonstrable reflux of the Saphenous Veins, there is no assurance that removal of these refluxing veins will have any effect on symptoms.

Duplex ultrasound examinations are usually administered by ultrasound vascular technicians. The technicians' skills and expertise can vary as do their results. You should obtain detailed copies of all your ultrasound reports and compare them. If there is a wide variation in findings you need to discover which findings are accurate and which are not. Very often, people undergo Endovenous Ablation and Sclerotherapy treatments when they were completely unnecessary.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Hratch Karamanoukian, MD, FACS, RVT, RPVI, RPhS

Published on May 17, 2016

You need to be evaluated in an accredited vascular lab by a certified physician who interprets the scans (RPVI credential). The accredited facility means that the tests are standardized and there are strict criteria for diagnosis and quality control. Once you get the exam, you should be treated by a certified vein specialist from the ABVLM.

In my office, we have an ACR-accredited vascular lab. The scans are done by myself (RVT, RPhS) or two other vascular technicians (RVT credentials). I am in the clinic and come in the room to talk to the scanners as they are doing the scans and offer advice. I officially read the scans using my RPVI (Registered Physician in Vascular Interpretation) credential.

I use that information and see the patient in consultation or follow up. I examine the patient. I make treatment plans. I happen to be certified by the American Board of Venous and Lymphatic Medicine. I am double board certified in surgery and thoracic surgery (cardiothoracic surgery).

Hopefully, you will find well-trained physicians/surgeons with ultrasound credentials in your area.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/7743_1538076833.jpg
Answered by Hratch Karamanoukian, MD, FACS, RVT, RPVI, RPhS

You need to be evaluated in an accredited vascular lab by a certified physician who interprets the scans (RPVI credential). The accredited facility means that the tests are standardized and there are strict criteria for diagnosis and quality control. Once you get the exam, you should be treated by a certified vein specialist from the ABVLM.

In my office, we have an ACR-accredited vascular lab. The scans are done by myself (RVT, RPhS) or two other vascular technicians (RVT credentials). I am in the clinic and come in the room to talk to the scanners as they are doing the scans and offer advice. I officially read the scans using my RPVI (Registered Physician in Vascular Interpretation) credential.

I use that information and see the patient in consultation or follow up. I examine the patient. I make treatment plans. I happen to be certified by the American Board of Venous and Lymphatic Medicine. I am double board certified in surgery and thoracic surgery (cardiothoracic surgery).

Hopefully, you will find well-trained physicians/surgeons with ultrasound credentials in your area.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Lafayette Regional Vein & Laser Center

Published on May 13, 2016

This is an important question....

If the ultrasounds were performed while you were lying on your back, you should not trust findings of reflux. If you were standing and have had multiple scans with reflux, you may indeed have reflux. The bigger concern seems to be that you have no physical findings of varicose veins nor swelling (edema). Heaviness and aching are common vein-specific symptoms. If your symptoms are minimized with walking, wearing compression and elevating them above the heart, you may indeed have a vein problem that WILL benefit from treatment. The key here is that you have vein symptoms suggesting reflux, yet an ultrasound that has proven to be inconsistent.

You need a standing ultrasound with a credentialed ultrasonographer. If reflux is present and your symptoms improve with compression, walking and elevation, you will likely see a meaningful benefit from treatment. If you see no benefit from conservative therapy, you should not have treatment in our opinion.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/824_1499970480.jpg
Answered by Lafayette Regional Vein & Laser Center

This is an important question....

If the ultrasounds were performed while you were lying on your back, you should not trust findings of reflux. If you were standing and have had multiple scans with reflux, you may indeed have reflux. The bigger concern seems to be that you have no physical findings of varicose veins nor swelling (edema). Heaviness and aching are common vein-specific symptoms. If your symptoms are minimized with walking, wearing compression and elevating them above the heart, you may indeed have a vein problem that WILL benefit from treatment. The key here is that you have vein symptoms suggesting reflux, yet an ultrasound that has proven to be inconsistent.

You need a standing ultrasound with a credentialed ultrasonographer. If reflux is present and your symptoms improve with compression, walking and elevation, you will likely see a meaningful benefit from treatment. If you see no benefit from conservative therapy, you should not have treatment in our opinion.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


The Sheen Vein Institute

Published on May 13, 2016

Welcome to the world of vein treatment. There are a lot of people who treat vein issues, but not many actually know what they are doing. With that said, based on your comments, it definitely sounds like you have vein issues of some form, especially given the fact that you have heaviness and aching in your legs. One thing you must understand: Vein disease is not the cosmetic issue that most people, including doctors, tend to believe; it is a primary venous circulatory defect. Cosmetic issues do not generate symptoms, thus the heaviness and aching. As for which specialist to believe, that can be a difficult question to answer without actually scanning your leg veins. One thing that I would say is make sure your vein doc is a "phlebologist," someone who treats vein disease. Vein disease is not a vascular surgery or general surgery or dermatology issue; it is a phlebology issue, which is a completely different speciality. Furthermore, the doc who is evaluating you should perform a more thorough ultrasound evaluation of your legs looking for reflux and should be able to show you what is and is not refluxing by actually showing you the ultrasound screen and explaining to you what you are seeing--pictures do not lie. That said, once you settle on the one you trust, in order for your symptoms to resolve, that doc needs to address "ALL" aspects of your vein structure, from deep in your leg all the way out to your skin. Only then can they adequately fix the venous circulatory issues that are causing your symptoms. A doc who only recommends treating your larger veins deep inside your legs and calls everything else at skin level cosmetic, really has no idea what they are doing. Find someone else. Trust your gut and find the doc who knows what they are doing.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/1116_1499984661.jpg
Answered by The Sheen Vein Institute

Welcome to the world of vein treatment. There are a lot of people who treat vein issues, but not many actually know what they are doing. With that said, based on your comments, it definitely sounds like you have vein issues of some form, especially given the fact that you have heaviness and aching in your legs. One thing you must understand: Vein disease is not the cosmetic issue that most people, including doctors, tend to believe; it is a primary venous circulatory defect. Cosmetic issues do not generate symptoms, thus the heaviness and aching. As for which specialist to believe, that can be a difficult question to answer without actually scanning your leg veins. One thing that I would say is make sure your vein doc is a "phlebologist," someone who treats vein disease. Vein disease is not a vascular surgery or general surgery or dermatology issue; it is a phlebology issue, which is a completely different speciality. Furthermore, the doc who is evaluating you should perform a more thorough ultrasound evaluation of your legs looking for reflux and should be able to show you what is and is not refluxing by actually showing you the ultrasound screen and explaining to you what you are seeing--pictures do not lie. That said, once you settle on the one you trust, in order for your symptoms to resolve, that doc needs to address "ALL" aspects of your vein structure, from deep in your leg all the way out to your skin. Only then can they adequately fix the venous circulatory issues that are causing your symptoms. A doc who only recommends treating your larger veins deep inside your legs and calls everything else at skin level cosmetic, really has no idea what they are doing. Find someone else. Trust your gut and find the doc who knows what they are doing.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Advanced Vein Center

Published on May 13, 2016

First of all, do both legs hurt? I don't care what the ultrasound shows; if a patient has no complaints, I'm not going to treat them. Too many people are being treated who don't require it. If they have complaints, do compression hose help? If not, then treatment will not probably help and the discomfort might well be musculoskeletal in nature. I do an orthopedic exam on these patients and frequently find arthritis, sciatica, etc., as the cause of "their" pain--even if they have varicose veins.

//imgs-origin.edoctors.com/imageresizer/image/user_uploads/58x58_85-1/doctors/464_1408044069.jpg
Answered by Advanced Vein Center

First of all, do both legs hurt? I don't care what the ultrasound shows; if a patient has no complaints, I'm not going to treat them. Too many people are being treated who don't require it. If they have complaints, do compression hose help? If not, then treatment will not probably help and the discomfort might well be musculoskeletal in nature. I do an orthopedic exam on these patients and frequently find arthritis, sciatica, etc., as the cause of "their" pain--even if they have varicose veins.

Published on Jul 11, 2012


Related Questions for General

General -7 answers
I have pertruding veins on the top of my hands. I have not been drinking enough water. Can dehydration be the cause of my bulging hand veins? What about caffeine?
See More
General -1 answer
I have always had visible veins in my legs. Recently I started my career in yachting which requires walking or standing all day. After a two week charter, the veins in my legs have become extremely visible and there seem to be many more showing than usual. The sight of it is embarrassing and I would like to know what the cause of this may be and what I can do to get normal looking legs. I read somewhere that it may be due to leaking valves? Also, I am also prone to bruising easily.
See More
General -4 answers
I'm 26 and have 2 kids. The veins in my legs hurt and swell so much during my menstrual cycle that it's hard to walk. What's going on?
See More
General -3 answers
I used to work nine hours a day, and never had this swelling problem before. Now that I'm retired I've been having this swelling problem for about a year. I wake up with swollen feet and ankles and they stay this way all day. Compressions socks help a little bit. I'm under 65 years old, and am no longer very active. I don't have medical insurance. What should I do?
See More
General -4 answers
I hate my arms and hands and cover them all the time. The veins are very green and quite large as I only have a small frame. Can they be treated?
See More
General -7 answers
My feet are freezing despite wearing compression socks. Is this normal? I'm waiting to hear back from my specialist, but wanted to seek advice prior to our follow up. My GP thinks it might be lymphedema. Could it be?
See More
General -7 answers
The results of my Ankle Brachial Index are as follows: left side 0.85; right side 0.87. I am doing a lot of walking. Do compression stockings help with PAD?
See More
General -1 answer
Bulging veins, peach-pit sized lump, red, swollen. Located between my bikini line and upper inner thigh. Doesn't appear to have a point where it should come to a head. Appeared around the start of my period.
See More
General -1 answer
I'm 28, body fat of 18% (I weight lift and dance), and I've relapsed with my eating disorder for a few months now. I've recently noticed 3 vertical bulging veins in my lower abdomen (where my waist band lays), and now I have two bulging on my left hip and smaller ones on my right. I don't notice any pain stemming from them, they're just puffy all the time. I binge and purge about once a day, and I rarely drink water (only caffeine).
See More
Get answers from our experienced doctors.
How it works
General -1 answer
My 8-year-old daughter has visible, prominent green veins in her hands, legs, upper chest, and sides of stomach. She is healthy and has no associated problems. The pediatrician said they look normal when he saw her three months back, but the prominence has increased and we are worried. She has no pain, just veins that can be seen clearly through the skin. Is this normal? Will they get normal once she gets older? She was born preterm and had IV fluids/medications given. Is that the reason?
See More
General -8 answers
Is GSV reflux 3.5 second considered to be serious? I am very symptomatic with heavy and achy legs. Elevation and walking helps some. Will I benefit from the vein closure procedure? What are the benefits vs risks? How should I weigh this?
See More
General -3 answers
I had surgery on my knee about 8 weeks ago. Everything was great. I even went to see the doctor 2 times for post op checkups and everything was fine, things were healing well. About 2 days ago a red rash popped up and there were splotches all over my legs. I showed the doctor, a pharmacist and a nurse, and they thought it was blood clots and told me to go to the ER. I went to the ER and they told me that nothing was wrong. They did an ultrasound on my leg to make sure it wasn't blood clots.
See More
General -4 answers
I have had varicose veins for 12 years. Just recently, I began doing things I don't normally do, like a lot of squats. Now, for the past four days, I have a burning sensation and sharp, tender pain. The pain is worse upon standing, squatting and bending over. It is also warm to the touch. Did I overdo it? Also, is the warmth normal? Going to make an appointment, I just want to know if this can happen. I've had pain in the past but it would go away soon after rest.
See More
General -3 answers
I have a bulging vein that is is not red, but it is raised and it's quite noticeable on the front of the thigh.
See More
General -6 answers
I was diagnosed with CVI last year. I have heavy, achy legs all the time. I am wearing 20-30 mmHg thigh-high compression stockings daily. My parents are overseas. I know I will not take flight unless absolutely necessary. If I need to take a 12-15 hour flight for an emergency situation, is it safe? A business class seat is a must and so is walking in the cabin every hour, but what else can I do to prevent DVT?
See More
General -1 answer
I am 23 years old and I have developed a varicose vein on my penis. The vein gives me slight discomfort. Will this or can this cause pain during sex in the future? Is there a treatment for penile veins? If so, it is safe?
See More
General -2 answers
Hi. I started taking an antibiotic for an infected wound two days ago. The infection seems to be getting better but there is still pus coming out of the wound. Should I see a doctor about that or just keep taking the antibiotics? Thanks.
See More
General -1 answer
A vein which splits right above my vastus medialis is swollen and it hurts to touch the vein near the split and farther down my leg towards my foot. Above the split, the vein goes deeper into my leg and it doesn't hurt there. I think it started hurting after I did some light squats in gym class, but it's been four hours since I noticed the pain, and it's still there if I flex my leg and pump the muscle. It takes a long time for the vein to stop being vascular. Is this normal?
See More
General -4 answers
I have CVI in both legs. I have heavy and achy legs all the time. My left leg has more severe symptoms than my right leg. But numerous ultrasound reports show very mild reflux on my left leg and significant reflux on my right. Why is my left leg having unbearable leg pain and so much more severe symptoms? I never had DVT. Could it possible that I have MTS?
See More
Get answers from our experienced doctors.
How it works

Related Articles

Have specific questions?
ASK A DOCTOR